My Top Ten Romantic Movies

I was struck with inspiration today morning while listening to the B’lore radio channels, as I was travelling from home to office: Inspiration to post my favorite romantic movies - movies which I can watch again and again, movies which have swayed my heart, made me believe in love, and defined some part of my idea of pure love… and so, here are the top ten ones, in random order (I’ve tried to intersperse the languages though - one English movie, one Hindi, one English again and so on..):

1. Titanic

Titanic

A very safe choice :) but also a very personal one…Titanic still takes my breath away, each time I watch it. Beautifully crafted, taut and perfect, the movie leaves no loopholes, and the love between Jack and Rose is almost immortal. Leonardo Di Caprio is fiery, charming yet mature, a man who believes in living every moment to the fullest. Kate Winslet is beautiful, strong, passionate and a woman of substance. Their love seems improbable at first, but after they meet, inevitable. If I were to list favorite scenes, I would almost be rewriting the movie, so for now I mention only these: the look on Jack’s face when he sees Rose for the first time, on the upper deck, Jack’s performance on the dinner table - and him saying “Almost”, when Cal tells him he could almost pass for a gentleman; Rose reading the words “Make it count. Meet me at the Clock”, the flush on her face as she tap dances with Jack, and discovers the free-spirited life she’d been yearning for, Rose coming back for Jack when she realizes he’s not gotten onto the boats, Jack dying trying to save Rose… The last scene is perfect - the lovers are united under the clock, where time and life stop for their divine love - I still get tears when I watch that one.

2. Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge

Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge

Who could be more corny and irritating than Raj in the first half of DDLJ, yet be able to win the heroine and us over in the second half with his undying love and promises, and who could be more endearing than Simran, who cries, screams, shouts, gets sozzled, and yet has stars in her eyes… DDLJ is the atypical romantic movie, one of the best movies Hindi cinema has seen. 5 yrs and still going strong. My favorite scenes would again fill a whole page, but some notable ones I can think of immediately is: Raj and Simran shouting at each other, then having to say sorry, when the other one says “bade bade deshon mein aisi choti choti batein hothe rethe he”; Going their separate ways after all their escapades, and turning back to see the other one walking away; Raj meeting Simran in the mustard fields of Punjab - where he’s come to take away his bride; the scene in the kitchen where Raj tells Simran’s mum “bas, samjho ki aap ki hi parchayi honi chaahiye”, and the subsequent look on Simran’s face; them meeting chori-chori chupke-chupke on the terrace, and Simran’s ploys to get Raj to give her food and water on karva chaut, and to avoid Kuljeet put a ring on her ring finger… I think I’m already running out of space :).

3. Dil To Pagal Hai

Dil To Pagal Hai

I haven’t seen Silsila and other Yash Chopra movies much, so for me Dil To Pagal Hai is his best. Being into dance myself, Dil To Pagal Hai was a movie that resonated with my being. I watched this when I was in college, and was in DTPH fever for months altogether. I loved it - from the promos, to the songs, to the dialogues to the concept of “someone, somewhere is made for you”. That line has stuck with me the longest, and I have only Yash Chopra to blame for me not finding a mate yet - cos I believed in it :). Shahrukh as Rahul, Madhuri as Pooja and Karishma as Nisha. They had it all - the moves, the grooves. The whole movie traces the making of a play, and Shahrukh and Madhuri fall in love as they enact ‘Maya’… and the climax finds them rewinding through all the songs, on stage. Memorable scenes: The tune Shahrukh hums when he’s in the changing room at a store, when he’s going back home after the Valentine’s day party, when he’s delivered a cake to Madhuri’s home and is leaving, when he’s dropped her home and as he’s going back, he hums it and then she realized it was him all that while, the Kathak piece Madhuri does with Shahrukh on the drums, the Arere song (with two pairs of Madhuri-Shahrukh: one in actual life, and the other in love, watching them live their lives, but realizing the strong undercurrent of love between them), the scene after the wedding when Madhuri loses her choodiyan, the dance of envy and Karishma’s almost-green eyes… again running into pages :)

4. Pretty Woman, The Runaway Bride

Richard Gere and Julia Roberts

I had no choice but to list these two movies together - and that’s only because of the star pair. Richard Gere and Julia Roberts created magic on the silverscreen - fantastic chemistry in the most improbable situations. I was all eyes for Gere and Julia Roberts - never knew why there was so much hype about her smile till I saw these movies. She can only be described as sparkly. Gere is suave and dashing. Memorable Scenes from both the movies: Gere running after his runaway bride, and she in her bridal wear hopping on a (Fed-Ex?) van; Julia coming back to Gere afterwards and the emotional moments in his apartment, with her proposing to him on one knee; In Pretty Woman, Julia going to an upmarket store and them being rude to her because of her sleazy outfit, and then Gere taking her to another one where she’s treated like a queen; Gere coming after her at the end, and climbing up (stairs?) to propose to her.

5. Maine Pyar Kiya

Maine Pyar Kiya

Listing Maine Pyar Kiya after Pretty Woman et al, may seem blasphemous to many, but not for me. I first heard of the movie Maine Pyar Kiya during my summer hols after completing 4th standard in school and going to the 5th. I remember my uncle telling me that it was a ridiculous movie about love. That year, we had a new school bus driver - I remember him very well - devout muslim with a beard, wearing a white prayer cap - although he appeared fierce as a person, in reality he was pretty jolly, always smiling and having a booming laugh. Every day when we went home he would play the Maine Pyar Kiya cassette in the school bus, and I would listen to the song “Mere Rang Mein” - not understanding a single word, but wondering what sort of music it was, because I’d never heard something like that before.
Initially I got tired of listening to the same song over and over again ( I remember each time the song got over he would rewind and play it again ) but then it grew on me. To this day when I hear the song, its like déjà vu; I’m transported to a totally different place. I saw the movie much after I’d heard its songs, and that’s when Cupid struck an arrow in my heart. No, I didn’t have any real life crushes, but I was in love with the movie - the innocence of Suman, and the mischief of Prem, and their dosti. Feelings of romance and love are so strong in adolescence (as my friend The Visitor puts it, probably an effect of hormones ;)), but however clichéd some parts of Maine Pyar Kiya were, it still ranks as one of the most romantic movies I’ve seen. I got to see it on TV a couple of weeks ago, and I realized I still stick to that.

6. You’ve Got Mail, Sleepless in Seattle

You've Got Mail

Double listing again :) courtesy Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan. I looovvvee Tom Hanks and I loved his pairing with Meg Ryan. What can I say about both the movies? Just very simply - all you mushy movie freaks out there - watch it. This one’s for you. For months after watching You’ve Got Mail, I wished fervently that I would also fall in love online. I logged onto yahoo chat with my incessant prayers, and the first few episodes of chatting jolted me to ground level, straight from the clouds - suffice to say that there were some unpleasant encounters, and although I did make some friends, I realized I couldl never fall in love without seeing and knowing any person. I guess I realized that movies were far removed from reality. Don’t want to list any particular moments from either of the movies btw, because I was captivated more by the lead pair, and how believable they made the stories seem.

7. Mughal-E-Azam

Anarkali and Salim. A tribute to love, dated back to almost a half-century ago. Re-made in color recently, and since has been playing out on Sony MAX almost every weekend. I never watched Mughal-E-Azam in black n white, so when it released in color, I made sure that I went to watch the larger than life, opulent movie, in PVR cinema’s plush cinema hall, in Bangalore. That was my first movie in PVR :). I’ve also watched the movie since then many times on Sony MAX, just because I could never take in the richness of the movie at one/two goes. Sony MAX plays out interesting tidbits during ad breaks - here’s one tidbit: When Jodhabai waits for her son to return from the army, years after he’s left home, there is one shot where a lot of pearls are thrown on the ground - Supposedly that shot was first done with fake pearls, but the maker of the film, K Asif, didn’t like the fact that the fake pearls didn’t bounce after hitting the ground, the way real pearls did. So he actually suspended shooting of the movie for a whole year, till they could accumulate enough real pearls to do that one shot! Getting back to the romance in the movie - I’ve heard a lot of people say that the scene where Salim caresses Anarkali’s face with a feather is the most passionate scene ever devised. I guess that says a lot for the jhatkas, matkas and stripping we see in movies of today. I don’t think any heroine of today can be what Madhubala was then - she was ethereal, so complete a performer. Strong and defiant, yet passionate and devoted, she was a revelation to me when I saw the movie. Her soft, romantic song “More Panghat Pe Nand Lal” song is so different from the classic “Pyaar Kiya tho Darna Kya”. In both songs, the hero sits on a throne away from the heroine; there is no physical contact, and no in-your-face moves at all - yet there was sheer electricity in the scenes.

8. The Wedding Planner

The Wedding Planner

This last one year I must have watched this movie atleast 50 times. Each time its on Zee Studio, HBO or Star Movies, I’ll be there watching it. So much so that I can recite all the dialogues with ease, maybe even show the facial expressions :). JLo is the wedding planner par excellence who lives a lonely life with no wedding bells for her in sight, and Matthew McConaughey is the doctor (paediatrician) who knows how to ballroom dance, and is engaged to a rich, adventurous and exciting but skinny woman. Their paths cross, and Mary falls in love with Steve, only to find out that she’s supposed to be planning his wedding. Amazing chemistry, scenes straight out of romantic fantasies, and finally a happy ending. My fav scene is the dance where JLo is wearing an amazing red dress, and Steve and Mary dance with aplomb (I’ve often tried practicing those moves :)) while yelling at each other the whole time. And there’s a scene in Mary’s house, when she’s drunk - she’s lying on the sofa and mumbling to Steve, who is roasting marshmallows on a lit candle, and he removes this strand of hair that’s fallen on her face… If there are people out there who’re smirking right now: yes, yes, I confess. I’m an incorrigible romantic. A hopeless case.

9. Bombay

Bombay

I don’t know whether it was Manisha’s innocent and endearing smile, or Arvind Swamy’s dapper looks, A R Rahman’s eternal music or Mani Ratnam’s impeccable direction that did it for me, but Bombay has always stayed on my mind - as fresh as when I saw it first. The choreography of Kehna Hi Kya (not to mention the song) is just perfect - Manisha - she’s dressed in this white/cream outfit, looking divine - tries to evade Arvind during the whole song (which she is singing in a marriage) but he keeps following her; at times, her step ceases as she sees him and our heart beats cease too. Tu Hi Re (Uyire in Tamil) is a heart-rending song about love, pictured with the sea as a backdrop. Hariharan and Kavita put their heart and soul into the song, and I get goose bumps even when I listen to it today. Finally they fall in love and she, a Muslim girl from a village in Tamil Nadu, runs away from home, to join her Hindu beloved in Bombay. And together, they set up a beautiful life after marriage - have twin children with names like Kabir Narayan and Kamal Bashir, but then their dream-like story is shattered in communal riots in Mumbai, and their family is almost torn apart. There is a piece that Rahman has composed as the Bombay theme - flute and violin. It is one of the most beautiful instrumental pieces I have ever heard in my life; the kind I would expect to hear if I ever go to heaven :).

10. Nandanam

Nandanam

Nandanam is the only Malayalam movie I count here, because most Malayalam movies with a romantic track, either have a strong dose of comic timing, or social relevance, or family values. So even though there are many many movies where the romance was special to me, I’m not listing any of them here. Nandanam is an exception, because Nandanam was all about love. Again, Nandanam is a movie for which I can write almost all the dialogues because I’ve watched it so many times. What made Nandanam refreshing was Navya Nair’s portrayal of Balamani - I loved that character. Her chemistry with Prithviraj (Manu in the movie) was also amazing - they were a fresh pair, good looking, and simple - and so was their love. But what made Nandanam so special was not only their love, but the involvement of God in it. I don’t know if I am spoiling anyone’s suspense by writing this here (but what the heck, its been years since the movie’s been released) - Balamani is an ardent devotee of the Lord Krishna, but she’s only a servant in Prithvi’s household. However, her love for the God is so pure that the Lord comes to her in human form, and brings the twists in the story that finally lead to her marriage with Prithviraj. The movie ended with the note that if you believe strongly in any higher-power, regardless of what name you may choose to call it by, that power will make your ardent wishes come true.

There are many other movies that were straining to come into the list, but I opted them out only because I didn’t think the romance was the only significant part of the movie. Also, there are most probably many other movies which I haven’t watched but qualify for best romantic movies - but then I said this is “My list” :). So that’s my disclaimer for sceptics ;)

Posted in Movies.

73 Responses to “My Top Ten Romantic Movies”

  1. Ashish Says:

    do we have any hindi remake of Nandanam?

  2. Visitor Says:

    Hi Shikha,

    First on the reviews - if one can call them reviews - ;) are excellently written, you have the right words, never superfluous and bringing out the emotion. Of course they are more like promotions for the movies. LOL

    I don’t think I have seen any of the movies described, except maybe the Wedding Planner. Of course I’ve heard of most of the others. They all are definitley very romantic (mushy?), they atleast seem so from your descriptions.

    This leads me on to another thread - making a preliminary analysis and generalizations. A majority of the movies, have a fairy tale character. What do I mean by that - that is there is a chance element and a magic moment, in how love strikes. Samples - Titanic, Pretty woman, You’ve Got mail, DTPH, Wedding Planner and Bombay. These things dont happen in real life - like for instance - someone, somewhere is made for you.

    Sorry to be a dampener of spirits, :( .

    Movie making is all about catering to our senses, visual, aural, physical, sensual etc. And scenes are planned such that these sensations are maximised to the viewers. So a ‘good movie’ is a movie which has a good collection of such scenes that appeal to the majority of the audience. And you seem to be a person who loves to be awash in these emotions.

    Sorry for dissecting a romantic movie in this heartless fashion :).

    All said and done I too love mushy movies. I like to see people watching mushy movies, to see how they react to scenes.

  3. Cribananda Says:

    Interesting list. Needless to say, I haven’t seen a single Hindi movie on it. I think I will check out some of them (with subtitles).
    I do have a couple of recommendations for the hopeless romantic: Il Postino (an Italian movie) and The Apartment. Of course, Casablanca lives forever….

  4. shikha Says:

    Ashish: Not to my knowledge. I don’t think the story would go down well with Hindi audiences either… unless they did some serious tweaking of the script. I think there were plans for remakes in other South Indian languages, but no idea whether any did materialize.

  5. shikha Says:

    Visitor:
    “Sorry to be a dampener of spirits, :(”

    Didn’t think of your comment as a dampener at all :). On the contrary I really enjoyed your POV.. and yes, you are absolutely right about movie making and the chance element in each of the movies!

    Here’s my POV now:

    What I love about the movies I’ve cited are that they have embodied the “fairy tale love” to a great extent without making it seem crass or artificial [I've seen other movies which try and fail miserably btw].

    And I am fully aware that things really don’t work out the way it is portrayed in movies. As a child, and as a teenager, yes, I think I hoped to some extent that similar incidents would happen to me too, but then I’ve always been pounded from left, right and center, and told that life is not a fairy tale, and romance and love are not lifetime stuff. So my hopes remained hopes, and never turned into beliefs. Which also means that I can’t sue any moviemaker if my life doesn’t turn out the way his scripts sound ;)…

    I think we as viewers are also always fully aware that movies are a 2-3 hour flight into fantasy land. That’s probably why we don’t question too much or delve into the nitty-gritties of the story - cos then, we’d be told - its a movie after all,.. what else did you expect.

    And as for whether its right for movie makers to cater to our visual, aural, physical, sensual sense (that’s from you of course), I guess I find that acceptable. Although I’m not always open / open only to candy floss / romantic movies, and do like watching other genres and good cinema, I would occasionally want to watch mushy stuff too, cos I guess that’s my escape from reality.

    What would be realistic material in cinema, when it comes to relationships? Marital discord, arguments about me and you, abusive relationships, parental problems, multiple relationships etc etc… All of that I come across on a day-to-day basis. Things may not be as bad all the time, but a lot of women have told me that life with a partner is not as good as it seems on the outside. Its mostly about responsibilities, and not everything turns out as you want it to. The ones who do say that their life has turned out like a fairy tale are probably just damn lucky.

    So in the midst of all the chaos and unromantic stuff about love and relationships and marriage, maybe these movie makers are giving us a vent for escape. And when I pay to go watch a movie, I think as much as I am aware that the story and its premise may not be real, I feel positive and different after I watch it :). Which reminds me that it is the same effect when we read a romantic novel, or a story about love…

    One addendum: Whenever I say candy-floss or hear the word, it reminds me of Karan Johar. So just to make a point, I dislike all of Karan Johar’s movies, because none of them struck a chord with me. I found the stories ridiculous and the romance in them boring.

    One more addendum: This is a B I G comment isn’t it :).

  6. shikha Says:

    Cribananda: Sadly, I haven’t seen Casablanca. But I think I should try to… read in many places that the movie is the It thing when it comes to romance.

  7. Sid Says:

    Dear Shikha,

    I dont know whether you agree with me ,

    i find the love story story between kareena and vivek oberoi in Yuva to be the best.it was fresh and vibarant.

    In the movie HOSTAGE the evil guy and the daughter of the guy who has been held to ransom. i found it quite dark and itense.

    Plus the romance between amitabh and jaya in sholay …they say so much without even whispering a word.

    See love comes in many forms.Each has it own interpretation.

  8. cookie Says:

    All the movies are really enjoyable. About Nandhanam, one thing about the movie I really loved- Lord Krishna. I felt the actor who played the role of Krishna was really perfect. There was something divine and sweet about him. I dont know the actor’s name though.. in a romantic movie, this idea would have dampened the chances of it becoming a hit… had it not been for good direction… I’m glad the movie does not have a remade- hindi version. We know what happened to Manichitrathazhu….(thats one movie i really loved!) But a version with sub titles would be quite helpful! I liked your views Shikha. Will look forward to more. :)

  9. shikha Says:

    Sid: Yes, the love track in Yuva between Kareena’s character and Vivek was refreshing. In fact, I didn’t like the Yuva one as much as its Tamil version Ayudha Ezhuthu where the same characters were played by Trisha and Siddharth… I’m pretty partial to Siddharth, that’s why ;).

    I haven’t seen Hostage, so I guess I must see it now :). As for the romance btn Jaya and Bachchan in Sholay - Sholay was a landmark movie. And even thou both the romantic tracks were diametrically different, they were appealing, because when one was out there in your face, the other was so subtle and was like a hidden connection. I loved both the tracks btw :)

    “Love comes in many forms. Each has its own interpretation”.

    Well said. I’d like to add: ” … and for each, his/her own way of love”.

  10. shikha Says:

    Cookie: Thank you :).. Looking forward to seeing you here more often!

    The name of the actor who played Krishna in Nandanam is Aravindan. He was seen in a Tamil TV soap for some time, and he’s into dance quite a bit - I believe now he’s more into Western though. I thought he was perfectly cast as Krishna - he had that impish look about him, and was totally sweet :). I was totally bowled over after watching the movie - one cos I am a Lord Krishna devotee too, two because of that totally unexpected twist in the movie - I just didn’t see it coming, and I had goosebumps when I saw it first in the theatre, in the last scene where Balamani sees the Lord Krishna in front of the guruvayur temple and realizes that it was him all along, and three because of Aravindan’s act as Krishna. As you said, the direction was impeccable too.

    Would I watch a remake? Nope. I don’t think that blend of good direction, script, dialogues and acting would come again. And most probably the script would be sacrifised in favour of more popular actors and their star images.

  11. Sid Says:

    http://www.indiafm.com/movies/review/12514/index.html

    shikha this is for you to read.

    Love is comin to you this friday.

  12. Sid Says:

    Behind every great love is a great story.

    The Notebook (2004)

    Heartwarming, heart-wrenching, poignant, emotional, conniving, manipulative and forceful romance tale based on the vastly successful best seller by novelist Nicholas Sparks tells the story of two young lovers (Ryan Gosling and Rachel McAdams) who fall for each other in rural Seabrook, North Carolina over one faithful summer in 1940. Naturally there are problems galore though as Gosling is a commoner who works at the local lumberyard and has no real prospects while McAdams is a socialite just visiting for the summer. Soon it is apparent that she is going to be heading for the women’s college Sarah Lawrence in New York City when the season is over. Her parents (caricature David Thornton and the always brilliant Joan Allen) are cold for the most part as they know that Gosling is way beneath their social standing. The typical romance between the classes becomes strained and it becomes apparent that the relationship may not work out. Gosling does not fret though as he swears to write to McAdams everyday. As time passes, the U.S. involvement in World War II forces Gosling and best friend Kevin Connolly (a real scene stealer) to go to Europe to fight for Patton’s Allied Forces. Meanwhile McAdams volunteers as a nurse in New York while attending school and instantly injured army man James Marsden falls in love with her. A short courtship, and the fact that he is from a wealthy southern family that her parents approve of, endears him to McAdams. She also falls in love with him, finally putting the hurt of her time with Gosling behind her (she never knows that Gosling’s letters are intercepted by Allen). Gosling returns from war and his loving father (a fine turn by the excellent Sam Shepard) has sold his home so Gosling can buy and fix up an old dilapidated house from the area. Gosling’s promise to McAdams to repair the old mansion during their summer fling drives him to brilliant work, but self-destructive emotional tendencies. He drinks uncontrollably, sheds himself from others and has a loveless physical relationship with young war widow Jamie Brown (in a well-timed and very convincing role). A crazy twist of fate then leads McAdams back to North Carolina. She finally starts to rekindle the immense love she once felt for him while his love for her continues to burn as bright as ever. We all know that there are consequences abound for McAdams though as she is now engaged to Marsden and still falls in line when confronted by her domineering mother. The whole story goes on through flashbacks as in the present-day a kind elderly man (arguably James Garner’s crowning achievement) reads to a fellow nursing home occupant (Gena Rowlands) who is suffering through Alzheimer’s Disease. The titled item is read to Rowlands everyday by Garner in the hopes that she will always be reminded of the story and hopefully always moved by it. My goodness “The Notebook” is an emotionally charged candy cane of near epic proportions that is so sweet that you might get diabetes watching it. The film does its best to persuade and make the audience feel the way it wants you to feel that it turns those watching into slaves to the story. So help me, I liked being a slave to this picture. It is not near as complicated and creative a story as it would make itself out to be, but it knows exactly which buttons to push and when to push them as the old Hollywood formula (which has been around since the late-1910s in the cinema) sucks its viewers in. This film is not as good as many wonderful romances of the past (everything seems mixed here from “Casablanca” to “It’s a Wonderful Life” to “Summer of ‘42″ to “Annie Hall” to “Cinema Paradiso” to “Titanic” to “Love Actually” and everything else in-between), but it will still grab and hug at you tightly. Nick Cassavetes (Rowlands’ real-life son) is a deceptively clever director that knows how to use tone and varying film-making principles to literally move his audience at will just as he would move his characters to perform in certain ways. No doubt there are shortcomings and flaws here as the movie runs too long and sometimes talks down to its audience. But with these things said the project is a smashing success that serves its purpose. Garner and Rowlands are amazing as they have basically a table-tennis match of roles when on screen. Gosling (best known as one of Denzel Washington’s players in “Remember the Titans” ;) and McAdams (who has a credit list of ho-hum films like “The Hot Chick” ;) do definitely have a heated chemistry that pulls you in almost immediately and never lets you go. The other actors are all perfectly placed with Shepard and Allen providing stellar screen-time and Brown (in admittedly a relatively small role) showing the makings of an individual who has the potential to have an exciting film career. Beautifully scripted by Jeremy Leven (maybe a bit too beautifully done if possible), “The Notebook” will engrave itself on you.

  13. Rohini Says:

    Hi. Thanks for dropping by. I am a big-time fan of the chick-flick movies as my husband likes to call them so let me more you with my opinions on the movies you listed (and the ones you didn’t)

    The ones that I felt deserved a mention were When Harry Met Sally, Love Actually, and Four Weddings and a Funeral. I have seen all of them atleast a dozen times and could still sit through them atleast a dozen more!

    Titanic - I know everyone loves this movie and thinks it is the epitome of romance but somehow it just didn’t touch a chord with me. Probably because I like my love stories to have a happy ending…

    DDLJ - The best Hindi romance flick EVER. There was a time when I could mouth all the dialogues of the movie while watching it!

    DTPG - Didn’t like this one much either. I don’t really like love triangles so much. I think they are very exaggerated in the movies and it rarely happens like that in real life.

    Pretty Woman - “She rescues him right back”. Need I say more…. I thought that the Roberts-Gere didn’t come up to the Pretty Woman standards in Runaway Bride though.

    MPK - I really really loved this movie when it first came out. But I really can’t sit through it anymore. It is just too corny. This says it better than I can.

    You’ve Got Mail/ Sleepless in Seatle - I adore Meg Ryan and both these movies are just lovely. While on Meg Ryan, I also loved Addicted to Love and French Kiss. And of course my absolute all-time favourite When Harry Met Sally.

    Mughal-e-azam - Beautiful classic but found it a bit slow when I watched it again.

    Wedding Planner - Don’t know why, can’t explain it - but I love this movie too. My husband laughs at me everytime its on TV and I drop everything to watch it.

    Bombay - Brilliant! The Humma song sequence was such a beautiful and subtle way to show the ‘first night’

    Hope I haven’t bored you to tears or sleep. I’ll be back :)

  14. Rajiv Says:

    where’s dil-e-nadan.

  15. Umesh Says:

    Wow some serious discussion is thru.

    From your list my favourite is nandanam. The idea of nandanam is not original though, its a brush up from MT’s Ennu Swantham Janaki kutty. But Ranjith’s presentation of nandanam was very appealing and more commercial than MT’s version which made the movie one of my favourites. But somehow I had never put Nandanam in the love story genre.

    I like Titanic for its effects. I dont like tragic ending movies. I didnt watch Titanic the second time for the only reason that Jack dies in the end…

    DDLJ was my favourite when it got released. Now a days i dont find it appealing. I didnt like DTPH at all, though its my brother’s favourite flick.

    Overall i think i’m anti romantic movies.

  16. Sid Says:

    Dear Shikha

    Thoovana Thumbigal …i find this movie very romantic

    Mohanlal’s Jayakrishnan with his Thrisshur accent must be one of the best characters in Malayalam cinema history. He is a drunkard and a shameless womanizer, forever at war with his neighbor (Jagathi in a hilarious role). He is expected to marry Radha(Parvati) a family relative. But things become complicated when he falls for the more exotic and mysterious Clara (Sumalatha) a prostitute with whom he spends a night. Ashokan and Babu Nambootiri play Lal’s friends. One of the best scenes in the film is when Lal together with his friends kidnaps Jagati to threaten him and forever evict him from the disputed property. The dialogs are excellent and this is another Malayalam classic from Padmarajan. opinion. the movie is a revelation. a bold story. love versus lust..love doesn’t win. lust doesn’t loose the game also. the game of life is practically won by love, as lust takes a back door exit. clara the prostitute, not like the woman, who wants to go in to the profession because of her life problems, but because thats what she wants in her life. the central character of jayakrishnan played by mohanlal is beautifully drawn as her readily gets in the cast, with his twisted accent. he is bold and daring in the town, the most popular, but in his village, he is a humble landlord and a farmer, who is conservative. both faces of the character are safe with mohan lal. he again displays his genius as he eases through the rule. rest are just popping up characters. ashoka plays a skeptic friend. the directors brilliance is shown in so many shots like the song sequences, the time when clara is proposes by him. lats scene is a beauty…… in fact a 10 out of 10….. the boldest movie made at that time, even the directors of this age won’t dare such innovations now

  17. BalajiRaghavan.com » Blog Archive » When I begin to enjoy my life… Says:

    [...] Inspiring fida pointed me to the online radio and I am seriously enjoying it. I took time off from my other online addictions such as checking blogs, seeing lovely comments, reading news, and analysing latest visitors to my site. It kept my focus on the work while listening to better songs. Sometimes it also makes me smile while listening to the DJs jokes(sometimes pathetic). Overall I am living in a different world. Then it happens… the Internet decides to be funny and finally when get it behaves itself (making me to swear), my electricity goes off. Why does this happen to me [...]

  18. shikha Says:

    Rohini: Welcome to my blog! - yours is turning out to be a great source of entertainment, and valuable information for me :D

    And you haven’t bored me to tears either… I enjoyed reading ur opinions on each movie. Here’s my replies to a couple of significant ones..

    Somehow,I’ve missed When Harry Met Sally and Love Actually each time they run on HBO - been told by my friends numerous times that I should watch it, but I just haven’t been able to catch it in time. Will have to keep my eyes more open to the movie listing in the newspaper from now on… I’m told the Hindi movie Hum Tum is ‘inspired’ from When Harry Met Sally btw.

    Titanic: I love stories with happy endings too; In Titanic’s case, I was a little inconsolable aftere Jack died, but then the ending where they meet in spirit soothed me a little.

    DTPH: Hmmm… don’t love triangles exist? Yes, maybe not as they’re portrayed in movies, but I’ve seen some in school/college though :)

    MPK: Now that review was hilarious! I had a great time reading it. Thanks!

    Wedding Planner: One of my friends (a guy naturally) also laughs each time I reply to his question of “what did you do over the weekend” with “watched The Wedding Planner yet again”.

    Bombay: Yup, I should have mentioned the Hamma sequence. I fell in love with Manisha after watching it - there was this naughty little jig she did behind the curtains, and a shot where she grins and beckons Aravind Swamy towards her with the index fingers of both hands… she was just oh-so-cute!

    Looking forward to you being back :)

  19. shikha Says:

    Rajiv: Dil-E-Nadan… :( haven’t watched it, so no idea about it!

  20. shikha Says:

    Umesh: I knew that Nandanam would be ur favorite in this list! :)… but was it inspired by Ennu Swantham Janaki Kutty? … I don’t know. Although both movies do have a spirit-visit as its central theme, I guess since the old Guruvayurappan-Devi centric movies (where the God pays a visit in human form) also had similar themes, Ranjit could have been inspired from them too. Anyhow, as you said, it definitely was a well presented movie.

    Anti-romantic huh? Hmmm… what happened to Mera Reputation :)

  21. shikha Says:

    Balaji: I’m glad the comments are entertaining you :).

  22. shikha Says:

    Sid: Thoovana Thumbikal…. wow. Images of Onnam Ragam Padi, and Mekham poothuthudangi flash in my mind as soon as I remember this movie. I loved it when I watched it first, although I was too young to comprehend the affair with the prostitute, or understand its implications in the script fully.

    Mohanlal was dynamite. It is one of the many movies which really infuse appreciation in me for the actors amazing talent and potential. Parvathi was young and raw, and Sumalatha’s name got added to my list of fav actresses after watching this movie.

    Sometimes I really rue the fact that we’ve lost brilliant craftsmen like Padmarajan and Bharathan, whose movies would be aesthetic, artistically infused and true entertainers. Comparatively most of today’s Malayalam movies seem either plain-cartoons or male-testosterone-directed-masala or pretentious-fare-in-the-name-of-art…

  23. Umesh Says:

    Thoovana Thumbikal is one of my favourites too. I never miss watching the movie whenever its shown on tv. The relationship between mohanlal and sumalatha is brilliantly etched in the movie and yes sumalatha became my favourite after this.

    But the best thing is Lalettan’s thrissur dialect and my other favourite sequence is when Lalettan and group kidnap jagathy.

    My favourite dialogue: King Fisher undoo???? Chillddduuuuu???

  24. Umesh Says:

    Btw Shikha, your next post can be your top ten favourite rain songs. Lemme suggest one…

    Oru madhura kinavin lahariyil engo….. :P

  25. shikha Says:

    Umesh: *Chuckle* I really did think of a similar post… After having written on rain, and lyrics of songs and then top ten romantic movies, I was thinking that all of it could amount to a new post on top ten rain songs :). I won’t attempt one right now, but maybe I will sometime later, and then I’ll keep your suggestion in mind…

  26. Msabe Says:

    Bonjour,

    I would like to add two indian movies:
    - Kabhi Kabhie’s one of Amitabh Bachchan’a greatest movies. ‘Kabhi Kabhie - Love Is Life’;
    - Oru Thalai Ragaam’s one of T Ragendran’s greatest tamil movie.

    Coordialement.
    MSabe.

  27. shikha Says:

    Msabe: Welcome, and thanks for those inputs! I’ve seen Kabhie Kabhie, but haven’t seen Oru Thalai Raagam - maybe I shd :).

    BTW, when I saw your comment (and the french in it), I was wondering how you were quoting Hindi and Tamil movies - but then I saw your site and the statement “I am Sri Lankan by birth, Tamilan by blood, French by education”. Interesting :).

  28. gooberof94 Says:

    what about Dirty Dancing. or Ten Things I hate About You

  29. Visitor Says:

    Some links for you:
    Link1
    Link2
    Link3
    Link4
    Link5
    Link6 ;)

  30. Umashankar Says:

    Hey came to ur site accidently looking for the song ‘Oru Madura Kinavil’ song…nice pictures :)…Dil tho pagal hai spoiled the list…else we were kind off on the same track…

  31. shikha Says:

    Umashankar: :) Thank you! Good to know our list almost coincides, except for DTPH… I thought that people wouldn’t agree with me on most counts since some of them aren’t typically romantic mould - and I chose them because for me, they either represent some special moments in my life, or movies that have had an impact on me and the way I think.

  32. Umashankar Says:

    Hey Shikha

    I have to back track on my statement…I agree with the first 2 films ..after seeing it closely i find the movies totally filmy..u live in a filmy world ..hehehe…hey but u seem to be a very interesting and talented…so i think ur taste should be better…so lonely in space u need to watch more romantic movies :)

  33. shikha Says:

    Umashankar: :D Yup, you’re absolutely right. I actually live in a totally filmy world. My friend often tells me that she never needs to see any films cos after I see one, I enact the whole movie with the dialogues, out to her. But I don’t think being interesting and talented should be any contradiction to my taste in movies / being filmy :)… my interest in movies indulges my passion for dance, music, story telling and drama - I’m the very ordinary viewer who wants to be transported to a different world while watching movies: I cry, laugh, agonize and bite my finger nails in those 2-3 hours, and with good movies, I take back some element of it with me, in my life.
    As for my taste being better - yeah, actually all the movies I catch are the ones on TV or the new ones in the theatre. Have not watched much of classics or ‘different’ cinema, so I’ll take your advice on that, and start looking at some of them too.

  34. Umashankar Says:

    other than for titanic i dont see any more that made me sad in this list….well then titanic was way back, so i guess i may not feel the same way now watching it…hey if u get a chance watch telugu movie called Geethangali..it was a very touching movie…looks like u dream of a prince who would come on a horse back and pick u and ride away..hehehe..it happens only in fairytale…or hindi movies…

  35. shikha Says:

    Umashankar: I’ve watched Geethanjali. Loved the songs in it. I liked(not loved) the movie, and although I knew the story before I watched the movie, I found it touching too… Mani’s style was impeccable.

    Hey, how did you know about my dream of the knight in shining armour on a white stallion… :D. I’m kidding of course. I have no such expectations in life, because anyway, I’m no princess :)

    But that doesn’t mean I don’t like such stuff on celluloid. I’m all for dream-like/fantasy stuff in books and movies - It’s my 3 hour escape into wonderland :).

  36. Umashankar Says:

    Dont tell me its 3 hours on a daily basis :).. I dont remember wen was the last time i read a book…i just day dream during my travel…need to get into reading habit…hey by any chance u in orkut ??

    Hey i remembered you today when i heard the song Oru Madura Kinavin…hehehe

  37. sid Says:

    Director: Kamal

    Music: Vidyasagar

    Cast: Dileep, Meera Jasmine, Navya Nair, Revathi, Janardanan

    Rating: 7/10 (if Meera wasn’t there then 3.5/10)

    Jew Colony is a small place in Kochi where Sachidanandan (Dileep) lives, who owns an antique shop which sells Gramophone records. Luyi uncle (Oduvil Unnikrishnan), ‘Saigal’ Yousuf and ‘Tabala’ Bhaskaran (Salim Kumar) are Sachi’s close friends.

    There are also a couple of Jews like Gregory (Janardhanan), an old Jew and his daughter Sarah (Revathi) and granddaughter Jeniffer (Meera Jasmine). They are the last of the Jews to migrate to Israel. Gregory dreams of going to Israel someday.

    Sachi’s father Raveendran (Murali) was a great music director, who died leaving him a lot of debts. Naturally Sachi hates music and has vowed, never to sing, even in his bathroom. Sachi leads his life doing all sorts of jobs that he can get his hands at. Jennifer works as a housemaid at a big hotel and is the best friend of Sachi. First half is full of small comedies by Dileep and Meera. Just before second half enters Pooja (Navya Nair), who is the daughter of Arya Devi. Arya devi was a former student of Raveendran. Pooja and Jenny become best friends.

    Gregory, who was looking for a way of returning to Israel finds an opportunity when an Israel soldier, returning from war asks for Jenny’s hand in marriage. Gregory is delighted and readily agrees. Jennifer, who has a soft corner for Sachi, agrees for her family’s happiness . Sachi is terribly upset as he also has a hidden place for Jenny, but does not express it.

    You’ll need lots of tissue papers for the second half, BUT there is an unexpected twist in the climax.

    Meera, as usual, is strikingly beautiful and excels with her acting while Dileep is, as usual, at his best. I think the only mistake Kamal made was Navya. She is so boring in this movie, AS USUAL. This movie is good for watching, but Kamal could has made it a little more exquisite.

  38. sid Says:

    the above mentioned story is of Gramaphone (2003) . i just saw yesterday on Surya Tv. Whatta movie… Meera Jasmine Rocks

  39. shikha Says:

    Umashankar: Yes, I’m in orkut. Who isn’t :)

    Sid: Yes, Gramaphone is a gr8 movie. I love the scene where Meera says “10,000 roopayil anjoorinte oru anju gandhi kuravundaayirunnu. Adichchu maattiyalle. Kallan” :D Btw, I think the name of the character Oduvil played was “Pattu Sahib”. Luyi uncle was the thin dark man who plays the clarinet.

  40. Valli Says:

    Saw you on Lakshmi’s orkut..
    Found your post interesting… But my top favs are:

    Idayathai Thirudathey & Alaipayudhey.

    Basically all Maniratnam love stories.

  41. shikha Says:

    Valli: I have 4 Lakshmi’s on my friends list, so which one would that be :)
    I did consider Alaipayuthey, because the chemistry between Madhavan and Shalini was fabulous… but I didn’t put it in this list finally, because it would fall a little below top 10 :). Maybe because I didn’t like to see them fighting in the latter half ;)

  42. Another visitor Says:

    That Malayalam movie was remade in Telugu…The actors remain fresh n innocent…named Ma Bapu Bommaki Pellanta
    Ma(our) Bapu(a renowned telugu artist, whose pictures of women r considered as a perfect telugu girl) bommaki(doll like girl) pelli(wedding)

  43. shikha Says:

    Another Visitor: Welcome to my blog [:)] and thanks,… that was interesting info for me, since I watch quite some number of Telugu movies.

  44. Pranay Says:

    hey the choice is really gud but haven’t u seen Bobby, Qyamat Se qyamat taq, Jojeeta wohi Sikandar

  45. shikha Says:

    Pranay:

    Welcome! I’ve seen QSQT, and yes, Aamir and Juhi were breathtakingly cute in that :)… but actually, I wouldn’t rate it as that much of a romance movie, because I simply don’t believe in the running away from home stuff. Also, I like happy-ending movies :), and the tragic ending wasn’t something I liked.

    JJWS: Its more of a fun movie about friendship, perseverence, school life etc, than just romance, which is why, although its one of my fav movies, I haven’t put it here. But it has definitely given us one of the most romantic songs of the decade - “Pehla Nasha”.

    Bobby: That’s one of my regrets :). Never seen the movie. Will try to though.

  46. Joe Says:

    Thoovana Thumpikal is my all time fav. If this were to me made in Hindi or Tamil
    who would your fav cast in mohanlal’s role?

  47. shikha Says:

    Joe: That is one difficult question!! I don’t think any actor can essay the role that Mohanlal did in Thoovana Thumpikal, with so much panache. It was a once-in-a-lifetime role, so there cannot be any remakes that would be as good.

    However, since I have to answer, here’s what I think: From Hindi cinema, I think Aamir Khan could try, since he has proven versatility when it comes to crass comedy as well as multi-faceted character roles. Of the current Tamil breed of heroes, I like Surya and Vikram. I haven’t seen Surya doing comedy, so maybe he would not fit here - Vikram may be better, but he would need a good director to pull out the best from him.

  48. sree Says:

    hi shikha

    i don’t kno y i comment.But it tap my mind “adieu my friend” ,me too had a same situation in my past.its a sugg to watch “sweet november”

  49. Shikha Says:

    Sree: Thanks for the comment! :) Will surely try to get my hands on Sweet November sometime…

  50. Visitor Says:

    A review of Nandanam on another blog

  51. shikha Says:

    Visitor: Read it :). I had the same sort of feelings when I watched the movie (prob because I’m also a naive Sagi :D). Have you watched it? I remember that there was talk that it was getting re-made in Tamil with Meera Jasmine as the lead, but didn’t hear about that afterwards…

  52. Vidya Says:

    funny, most of them I would like to have in my list of good romantic movies. Thanks to Visitor, I am here. and I see the visitor has already done some PRO for me. Thanks Visitor!I liked to read through your posts. Interesting. Have you seen, How to Lose a Guy in 10 days. Thats a good romace to see.

  53. shikha Says:

    Vidya: Welcome to my blog!

    Yes, Visitor is responsible for spreading a whole lot of cheer, information and awareness among the blogging community… she/he :), has in fact *created* a virtual community amongst a whole lot of bloggers, and is still adding new names to it… Great work Visitor! :)

    As for How to Lose a Guy in 10 days…no, I’d wanted to see the movie when it released but missed it for lack of company. Will try to pick up a CD and watch :)

  54. Balaji Says:

    How to Lose a Guy in 10 days, better than many romantic comedies, but not necessarily a great romantic movie.

  55. justin Says:

    i found your blog when i just stumbled upon it. I was looking for articles on Maine Pyaar kiya! and to my astonishment, its placed 5th in ur list of all time gr8 romantic movies!
    And to my wonder.. so many indian movies made it to the list. There is no doubt that MPK would be one of the classical romantic movies of all time.

  56. shikha Says:

    Justin: Welcome :). Good to know that your search for MPK let you here.

    I wasn’t trying to rank the movies actually (as I’ve mentioned in the post) - so MPK in the 5th place wouldn’t mean that I rate the next 5 movies on a lower scale. I like all the movies in the list for different reasons, and MPK definitely figures in the top ten for me (thou lots of the elitist club of movie-viewers may snub me for this ;)) - I like MPK for its sweet brand of romance - delicate and innocent - qualities which are out of date in today’s world…When MPK released, it was the stuff of dreams that all pre-adolescent children like me were seeing then…It was a wonderful time, and MPK brings in a lot of nostalgia for me :).

  57. The Bridges of Madison County « கதம்ப மாலை Says:

    [...] ஷிக்காவோட Top Ten Romantic Movies [...]

  58. Selvakumar Says:

    Finally saw “You’ve Got Mail” today. Good mushy movie - I love mushy movies. If no one is watching I don’t mind turning the tap on. :D
    I remembered that you’d reviewed it, so came back to have a look at your review. Meg Ryan is endearing as this young, cute, little, helpless thing. I’m a big fan of Meg Ryan. :)

  59. Shikha Says:

    Selva Sir: An official welcome!!! (since unofficially you’re anyways welcome ;)).. Thanks for the comment. Should have replied to it much earlier, but got lost and had to be in hibernation mode for sometime. But I’m back, and hence the reply!

    So one more supported for mushy movies…Great! :). And turning the tap on? Omigosh. I think that’s very sweet! Power to guys like you, who don’t associate crying with only women.

    As for Meg Ryan, yeah. She’s absolutely a cutie pie :)

  60. Surpraised Says:

    I am Surprised to see that Bombay makes to list. Not many agree that bombay is a romantic movie.. Its my favorite romantic movie as well..I rate it after titanic… coz it shows the completeness of the love. It’s a movie where feelings are in a perfect balance. The music creates magic… Although I am nowhere when it comes to singing or dance, I am a grrrrrrrrreat admirer of its music..
    my thanks..for listing Bombay here.. it needs a keen eye.

  61. Nikhil Says:

    Of all the movies on your list, I think I agree with DDLJ and Bombay, the others were a wee bit too mushy for me…Of course, that doesn’t mean I don’t like romantic movies. I mean I thought Message in a Bottle (if you’ve seen it) was great, as was Love Actually, and the Notebook…(Okay, maybe the Notebook was mushy too, but it had some real good moments that didn’t seem cheezy) or maybe its just that I like Rachel McAdams :P Anyhow…thats my 2 cents.

  62. sunil yadav Says:

    sunil (I love all romantic & comedy movie like titanic and golmal )

  63. Shikha Says:

    Surpraised, Nikhil, and Sunil: Enjoyed reading your two cents! :). Keep coming in and volunteering those opinions.

    Btw, Nikhil, haven’t seen Message in a Bottle. *Sigh*…one more addition to my romantic-movies-to-see list :).

  64. Visitor Says:

    Nothing related to the post - try this site - Celebrity Look-alike.

  65. k.s.selvakumar Says:

    Hello Shikha - First congratulations :)
    Now the grouse - I went and excitedly announced to Raman that your engagement photo was up on your blog - and imagine my chagrin when he promptly showed me an ‘album’ of 8 photos! :(

  66. Shikha Says:

    Selva Sir: *Chuckle*. First of all, Thank you!!
    And yes, apologies are due from my side - things happened suddenly, and I’ve been just so busy that I couldn’t let everyone know personally! So sneakily thought I’d put up a pic in flickr and let everyone do the guesswork ;) … hehe.

    Btw, you can have a look at all the pics in my album, at http://picasaweb.google.com/shikhagp/Engagement :)

  67. k.s.selvakumar Says:

    Thanks Shikha, I saw all the photos - you both look great together. :)

  68. Matthew Says:

    hey there i was just looking for a Romantic movie and i was just wondering what would be the best movie to see. can i please get the date that it is playng

  69. shaheen Says:

    hi shiksha!
    i like ur collection. But i seriously feel u left out alai payuthe…

  70. The Visitor Says:

    I recently saw ‘When Sally met Harry’ - Wow! Wow!! Surprised that a chronicler of romantic movies has missed even seeing this classic.

    It is not all candy floss either - a perfectly plausible tale.

    Get it today from the nearest CD/DVD store and see it with hubby. Have a great weekend.

  71. Shikha Says:

    The Visitor: Every time Star Movies plays WSMH, I end up watching only bits and pieces :(. But yes, this is a resolution - I will watch it and just as you suggested, I resolve to watch it with hubby ;) very soon!! Thank you!

  72. chetan Says:

    wow guys!!!!ya discussing movies haan…!!grt…my heart instead of normal lubb..dupp.. lubb..dupp it goes as film …dance..music…..n so on…
    i have watched it all u mentioned above….
    yaar do watch..sweet november and…a walk to remember…i wonder hw come dese names didnt come up….

  73. karan Says:

    hey,
    do you guys ever happen to watch a movie called ‘if Only’. Or the lakehouse, Sleepless in seattle , A Walk to remember even Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam should be in the list . And i complete agrees with the other person that bombay is not a completely romantic movie. there’s just a hint. sorry if i am wrong but you have to watch more movies and update the list. The world is full of more romantic movies.

    but i really appreciate the effort.

Leave a Reply